The Old Croatoan Cafe is located in North Carolina and is apart of the historial society there. It is owned and operated by Allison Doohan. The name comes from the tale of the lost colony of Roanoke.
Vince Teagues visited the cafe due to a lead during his investigation on Dave's past. Vince speaks to Allison for some information and she points him in the direct of the books that are in the cafe.